Nick Cormack is the owner and chef of the A&G Diner. He rarely speaks and can come off as cold, but he is widely appreciated for his cooking skill.
While investigating the murders in Greenvale, York becomes suspicious of Nick's demeanor and odd behavior. He discovers that Nick often drank with Diane after work and made frequent trips to the art gallery. York, Emily, Thomas and George decided to tail his car one night to try and catch him in the act after naming him a suspect. They find him unconscious on the floor of the gallery with Diane, bleeding slowly, hanging from the ceiling. He is then thrown in jail.
While behind bars, Nick opens up a little to York, even giving him a letter to take to his wife to try and explain his behavior. York is soon convinced of his innocence and works to get him out of jail. Nick's name is cleared after George reveals himself to be the killer.
- Although Nick's name is cleared, the player is never shown his release from jail. That fact is just assumed during the epilogue.
- If the player peeks through a certain window of the Cormack's house, its possible to see Nick's mini art studio all set up.
- Nick and Olivia sleep in different bedrooms, even after his name is cleared.